Tomato Variety and Yield Tracker
A printable multi-season log for tracking which tomato varieties you grew, sow / transplant and first / last harvest dates, total yield (lb + kg), quality 1-5 score, replant decisions, and problems / pests. Garden snapshot at top; annual variety log; problems and pests log; multi-year top performers summary; quick reference card with reliable short-season Canadian varieties (Sub-Arctic Plenty, Manitoba, Tiny Tim, Stupice), long-season varieties (Brandywine, Big Beef, San Marzano), and US + Canadian seed suppliers.
Pair with the Tomato Yield Calculator for harvest math, the How to Grow Tomatoes guide for the practice, the Vegetable Garden Area Planner for spacing, and the Soil Test and Amendment Tracker for soil-side year-over-year tracking.
Tomato Variety and Yield Tracker
Track which tomato varieties actually perform in YOUR garden, in YOUR climate. Annual variety log + problems log + multi-year top performers + quick reference card. Print one per season; archive at fall close-down for year-over-year comparison.
Annual variety log
| Variety name | Type | Source | Sow / transplant date | Spacing (in / cm) | First harvest | Last harvest | Yield (lb / kg) | Quality 1-5 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Type abbreviations: I = Indeterminate, D = Determinate, C = Cherry, P = Paste, H = Heirloom beefsteak. Quality 1-5 combines flavor + disease resistance + production reliability into one replant-or-not decision number.
Problems and pests log
| Date | Variety | Problem | Treatment | Outcome | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Common problems: blossom-end rot (calcium/pH), early blight (fungal, splashed from soil), late blight (fast fungal), cracking (erratic watering), blossom drop (heat stress), hornworms (caterpillar), septoria leaf spot, fusarium wilt.
Multi-year top performers (3-year rolling)
| Year | Variety | Type | Yield (lb) | Quality 1-5 | Replant Y/N | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A variety that scores 4 or 5 quality across 3 consecutive years is a keeper for your garden in your climate. A variety that scores 2 or below in 2 of 3 years should be dropped from the seed order. Note unusual weather years (drought, late frost, hot August) so a one-bad-year variety is not punished.
Quick reference: reliable short-season varieties (band 2 + 3, 60-70 days)
| Variety | Type | Days to harvest | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Early Girl | Indeterminate | 50 to 60 | Western US standard; reliable in Band 2 and warmer Band 3 |
| Stupice | Indeterminate | 55 to 65 | Czech open-pollinated; prolific in cool springs |
| Sungold | Indeterminate cherry | 57 to 65 | Most popular cherry; sweetest commercial variety |
| Bush Beefsteak | Determinate | 60 to 62 | Bush habit; container-friendly |
| Sub-Arctic Plenty | Determinate | 50 to 60 | Manitoba-bred at AAFC research station; the original short-season variety |
| Tiny Tim | Determinate cherry | 45 to 60 | Container / window-sill; very small fruit; reliable in any climate |
| Manitoba | Determinate | 60 to 70 | Open-pollinated heirloom; the prairie classic |
| Sweet Million | Indeterminate cherry | 60 to 65 | Cherry; very productive even in short seasons |
Quick reference: reliable long-season varieties (band 1 + warm band 2, 75-90 days)
| Variety | Type | Days to harvest | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Better Boy | Indeterminate | 75 | Reliable slicer; the home-garden classic |
| Big Beef | Indeterminate | 73 | Large meaty fruit; All-America Selection |
| Celebrity | Determinate | 70 | Disease-resistant; container or in-ground |
| Brandywine | Indeterminate heirloom | 80 to 100 | Best flavor of any tomato; harder to grow; pink-fruited |
| Cherokee Purple | Indeterminate heirloom | 72 to 90 | Smoky deep flavor; dark red-purple skin |
| Roma | Determinate paste | 75 | Determinate sister of paste line; canning concentrate |
| San Marzano | Indeterminate paste | 78 to 80 | The Italian canning gold standard |
| Sweet 100 | Indeterminate cherry | 65 to 70 | Cherry; long-vine vigor in long seasons |
Quick reference: Canadian seed suppliers
| Supplier | Location | Strength | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vesey's Seeds | York, PE | Short-season selection | Atlantic Canada catalog; excellent for cool maritime climates |
| Stokes Seeds | Thorold, ON | Broad commercial + home garden line | Largest Canadian commercial seed supplier; carries home garden quantities |
| West Coast Seeds | Delta, BC | Pacific NW focus | Strong tomato heirloom and short-season lines; certified organic |
| Annapolis Seeds | Middleton, NS | Atlantic-Canada heirlooms | Small farm seed company; rare Atlantic-region varieties |
| Tatiana's Tomatobase | BC | Heirloom tomato specialist | Largest tomato cultivar catalog in North America; hundreds of rare varieties |
Quick reference: US seed suppliers
| Supplier | Location | Strength | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johnny's Selected Seeds | Winslow, ME | Professional-grade | Maine-bred for short-season Northeast; trusted by market gardeners |
| Burpee | Warminster, PA | Mass-market | Widely available at retail; introduced Big Boy and Better Boy |
| Tomato Growers Supply | Fort Myers, FL | Tomato specialist | Tomato + pepper exclusive; hundreds of cultivars; mail-order only |
| Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds | Mansfield, MO | Rare and heirloom | Open-pollinated only; large rare-variety catalog |
| Territorial Seed | Cottage Grove, OR | Pacific NW focus | Bred for cool-climate Pacific NW gardens |
Quick reference: when NOT to grow tomatoes
| Condition | Why | Alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Less than 6 hours direct sun | Tomatoes set little or no fruit below 6 hours of direct sun | Lettuce, kale, chard, herbs (basil, parsley, cilantro), shade-tolerant greens |
| Soil pH below 6.0 without amendment | Calcium locks up; blossom-end rot is near-certain | Apply lime first; see Lime Application Calculator |
| Soil pH above 7.5 without amendment | Iron and manganese lock out; iron chlorosis | Apply sulfur first; see Soil pH Testing Guide |
| Season under 80 frost-free days | Even short-season varieties may not ripen reliably | Add row cover at start + end of season; pick Sub-Arctic Plenty or Manitoba |
| Soil with known fusarium or verticillium wilt | These soil-borne diseases persist 4+ years and devastate the crop | Plant resistant varieties (look for VF or VFN code on packets) or grow in containers with fresh potting mix |
| Container under 5 gallons | Restricts roots too severely; almost no yield | Step up to 15+ gallon container, or switch to determinate / patio variety in 5 to 10 gal |
Notes & observations
Frequently Asked Questions
Why track tomato varieties year-over-year?
Because seed-packet promises rarely match YOUR garden, in YOUR climate, with YOUR watering and fertilization habits. A variety rated 80 days to harvest in Iowa may take 95 days in Halifax, and a variety with 20 lb yield potential may produce 12 lb in shade you did not realize was there. Three years of logging gives you data: which varieties actually perform in your specific conditions, what your real average harvest is, which problems are recurring (and probably soil-related), and which years had unusual weather. The seed order in year 4 is based on real data instead of seed-catalog photography.
What yield quality score should I track?
A 1 to 5 combined score for flavor + disease resistance + production reliability is the simplest metric that captures everything that matters. 5 = excellent on all three (Sungold, Sweet 100, Cherokee Purple in many gardens). 4 = good on most (Better Boy, San Marzano). 3 = acceptable but with quirks (Brandywine, heavy fruit prone to cracking). 2 = struggled (variety not suited to your conditions). 1 = failed (do not replant). The combined number is more useful than three separate columns because it forces a single replant decision: would I plant this again?
How many varieties should I grow in one season?
For a typical family-of-4 home garden: 3 to 5 varieties across 8 to 12 plants. The rough mix: 1 to 2 indeterminate slicers (Cherokee Purple, Brandywine, Better Boy) for fresh eating; 1 to 2 paste varieties (San Marzano, Amish Paste, Roma) for canning; 1 cherry (Sungold, Sweet 100) for snacking and salads; optionally 1 short-season insurance variety (Early Girl, Sub-Arctic Plenty) so you have early fruit while the others ripen. For canning-heavy gardens or market gardeners: 8 to 12 varieties is normal, tracked in this log year after year.
Which Canadian short-season varieties actually work in the Prairies?
Sub-Arctic Plenty (Manitoba-bred at the AAFC research station, 50 to 60 days to first harvest), Manitoba (open-pollinated heirloom, 60 to 70 days), Tiny Tim (container/window-sill, very small fruit, ripens reliably even in pots), Sweet Million (cherry, 60 days), Stupice (Czech open-pollinated, 55 to 65 days, prolific in cool springs), Bush Beefsteak (62 days, bush habit, container-friendly), Early Girl (50 to 60 days, the western US standard short-season variety). All routinely ripen in 80-day prairie growing seasons; supplement with row cover the first 2 weeks for an extra week of growing time at the start.